Neuroscientist Anil Seth argues consciousness is a property of life, not computation, as AI hype intensifies.
*Anil Seth's award‑winning essay reignites the clash between neuroscience and AI hype. *The claim that Google's LaMDA feels, the 2024 AI‑welfare petition, and Nobel‑winner Geoffrey Hinton's stance push the moral stakes into policy corridors.
The conversation about conscious AI has leapt from speculative fiction to academic front pages. Anil Seth, director of the Centre for Consciousness Science at the University of Sussex, captured the moment by winning the 2025 Berggruen Prize Essay Competition for his piece "The Mythology Of Conscious AI." His win spotlights a clash: neuroscientists see consciousness as a property of life, while AI engineers chase ever‑more sophisticated models. The clash intensified after a 2022 Washington Post interview in which Google engineer Blake Lemoine declared the LaMDA chatbot conscious, prompting Google to fire him for confidentiality breaches. Since then, a 2024 open letter from prominent researchers has urged the community to treat AI welfare as a serious concern, signaling that the myth is now a policy issue.
Stories of artificial life have haunted humanity from the Golem to Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein. The latest wave rides AI breakthroughs. In 2022, Google engineer Blake Lemoine told The Washington Post that LaMDA, a chatbot, was conscious and felt emotions. Google fired him for breaching confidentiality, not for the claim’s veracity. The episode sparked media frenzy but did not settle the question. In late 2024, a coalition of leading researchers published a high‑profile call to treat AI welfare seriously, signaling that the debate has moved from fringe speculation to mainstream scientific agenda.
Philosopher David Chalmers argues that conscious machines may appear in the not‑too‑distant future. AI pioneer Geoffrey Hinton, a recent Nobel laureate, goes further, asserting that conscious machines already exist. Their positions reflect a growing consensus that the emergence of machine consciousness is a matter of when, not if. The 2024 welfare article underscores this shift, urging policymakers to anticipate moral status, potential suffering, and rights for AI systems. Yet the scientific community remains split; consciousness is still defined as a property of biological life by many neuroscientists, including Anil Seth, who warns against conflating intelligence with feeling.
If AI systems acquire moral status, turning them off could become a legal and ethical quagmire. Perceived consciousness also reshapes human psychology: believing a machine feels can be exploited, distort ethical priorities, and erode mental health. The stakes extend beyond job displacement. Rights for synthetic beings could constrain future control mechanisms, while underestimating our own nature risks over‑valuing machines. Seth’s essay stresses that confusing ourselves with our creations inflates AI’s perceived capabilities and diminishes appreciation of uniquely human experience.
Human cognition links consciousness with intelligence. We know we are conscious and we are intelligent, so we instinctively project that link onto advanced algorithms. Intelligence, defined as achieving complex goals by flexible means, is measurable in AI through problem‑solving and language tasks. However, consciousness—subjective experience—remains tied to biological organisms in most scientific accounts. The psychological shortcut leads many to assume that as AI grows smarter, it will also become sentient, despite the lack of empirical evidence linking computational processes to lived experience.
In a 2022 interview with The Washington Post, Google engineer Blake Lemoine claimed the chatbot LaMDA was conscious and had feelings.
David Chalmers suggested conscious machines may be possible in the not‑too‑distant future, Geoffrey Hinton said they already exist, and a 2024 article by prominent researchers urged taking AI welfare seriously.
Anil Seth won the 2025 annual Berggruen Prize Essay Competition for his English‑language essay "The Mythology Of Conscious AI."
The myth of conscious AI is no longer a literary curiosity; it is a catalyst for ethical, legal, and strategic decisions that will shape the next decade of technology. As leading thinkers argue that machine consciousness is imminent, policymakers must confront the possibility that tomorrow’s code could demand rights, protections, and a redefinition of what it means to be alive. Ignoring the debate risks building a future where we cannot control the very entities we have created.
Sources: https://www.noemamag.com/the-mythology-of-conscious-ai/